|
| Ona
Maria Judge |
|
|
| A house slave of George Washington, she
escaped by ship to Portsmouth in 1796. Washington attempted to get her
back without a fuss, but was unsuccessful. She married John Staines of
Portsmouth in 1797, and later lived on Dearborn Road until her death in
1848. The following passage is taken from A Pleasant Abiding Place, by Paul
Hughes, an unpublished manuscript available in-house use only at the Weeks Public Library. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
A drama which
would affect Greenland for many decades began in the summer of 1796. On
Sept. 1, a letter from George Washington, President of the United States,
was sent via Secretary of the Treasury Oliver Wolcott to Joseph Whipple,
Collector of the Port of Portsmouth. It referred to a house slave of the
Washingtons named Ona Maria Judge: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Enclosed
is the name, and description of the Girl I mentioned to you last night.
She has been the particular attendant on Mrs. Washington since she was ten
years old; and was handy and useful to her, being perfect Mistress of her
needle.
We have heard that she was seen in New
York by someone who knew her, directly after she went off. And since by
Miss [Elizabeth] Langdon [daughter of John], in Portsmouth; who meeting
her one day in the Street, and knowing her, was about to stop and speak
to her, but she brushed quickly by, to avoid it.
By her being seen in New York (if the
fact be so) it is probable she went immediately to Portsmouth by Water
from this city [Philadelphia]; but whether she travelled by land, or Water
to the latter, it is certain the escape has been planned by some one who
knew what he was about, and had the means to defray the expence of it and
to entice her off: for not the least suspicion was entertained of her
going, or having formed a connexion with any one who could induce her to
such an Act.
Whether she is Stationary at Portsmouth,
or was there en passant only, is uncertain; but as it is the last
we have heard of her, I would thank you [Wolcott] for writing to the
Collector of that Port [Whipple], and him for his endeavours to
recover, and send her back: What will be the best method to effect it, is
difficult for me to say. If enquiries are made openly, her Seducer (for
she is simple and inoffensive herself) would take alarm, and adopt instant
measures (if he is not tired of her) to secrete or remove her. To seize,
and put her on board a Vessel bound immediately to this place, or to
Alexandria [Va.] which I should like better, seems at first view, to be
the safest and least expensive. But if she is discovered, the Collector, I
am persuaded, will pursue such measures as to him shall appear best, to
effect those ends; and the cost shall be re-embursed and with thanks
besides.
If positive proof is required, of the
identity of the person, Miss Langdon who must have seen her often in the
Chamber of Miss Custis and I dare say Mrs. Langdon, on the occasional calls on
the girl by Mrs.
Washington, when she has been here, would be able to do this.
I am sorry to give you, or any one else
trouble on such a trifling occasion, but the ingratitude of the girl, who
was brought up and treated more like a child than a Servant (and Mrs.
Washington's desire to recover her) ought not to escape with impunity if
it can be avoided. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Joseph Whipple
replied to Wolcott on Sept. 10, "to assure you that I shall with
great pleasure execute the President's wishes in the matter... I have just
ascertained the fact that the person mentioned is in this Town." It
was only on Oct. 4 that Whipple felt able to report to Wolcott at length: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
On
the 10th Ultimo in answer to your letter of the 1st I advised you of the
President's servant's being in this town. -- Having discovered her place
of residence, I engaged a passage for her in a Vessel preparing to sail
for Philadelphia avoiding to give alarm by calling on her until the Vessel
was ready, -- I then caused her to be sent for as if to be employed in my
family -- After a cautious examination it appeared to me that she had not
been decoyed away as had been apprehended, but that a thirst for
compleat freedom which she was informed would take place on her arrival
here or [at] Boston had been her only motive for absconding. -- It gave me
much satisfaction to find that when uninfluenced by fear she expressed
great affection & reverence for her Master & Mistress, and without
hesitation declared her willingness to return & to serve with fidelity
during the lives of the President &his Lady if she could be freed on
their decease, should she outlive them; but that she should rather suffer
death than return to Slavery & [be] liable to be sold or given to any
other persons. -- Finding this to be her disposition & conceiving it
would be a pleasing circumstance to both the President & his lady
should she go back without compulsion, I prevailed on her to confide in my
obtaining for her the freedom she so earnestly wished for -- She made
preparation with cheerfulness to go on board the the Vessel which
was to have sailed in a few hours and of her own accord proposed
concealing her intention of returning from her acquaintance lest they
should discourage her from her purpose. -- I have recited this detail
to show the girl's good disposition when expressing her uncontrolled
sentiments and acting without bad advisers -- I am extremely sorry to add,
as I conceive the girl is a valuable Servant to her Mistress, that the
Vessel being detained by a contrary wind, in the course of the next day
her intentions were discovered by her acquaintance who dissuaded her from
returning and the vessel sailed without her. --
I am informed that many Slaves from the
Southern States have come to Massachusetts & some to New Hampshire,
either of which States they consider as an asylum; the popular opinion
here in favor of universal freedom has rendered it difficult to get them
back to their masters: -- In the present case if the President's servant
continues inflexible & will not return voluntarily, which at present
there is no prospect of, I conceive it would be the legal & most
effectual mode of proceeding that a direction should come from an Officer
of the President's Household to the Attorney of the United States in New
Hampshire & that he adopt such measures for returning her to her
master as are authorized by the Constitution of the United States, -- and
I shall be happy to facilitate the business to the utmost of my power in
obedience to whatever shall be the pleasure of the President - and it is
with great regret that I give up the prospect of executing the business in
that favourable manner that I at first flattered myself it would be done. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
It was not until
Nov. 28 that President Washington, apologizing for "an absence of
some weeks at Mount Vernon," replied to Joseph Whipple's letter of
Oct. 4: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I
regret that the attempt you made to restore the Girl (Oney Judge as she
called herself while with us, and who, without the least provocation
absconded from her Mistress) should have been attended with so little
Success. To enter into such a compromise with her, as she suggested
to you, is totally inadmissable, for reasons that must strike at
first view: for however well disposed I might be to a gradual abolition,
or even to an entire emancipation of that description of People (if the
latter was in itself practicable at this moment) it would neither be
politic or just to reward unfaithfulness with a premature
preference; and thereby discontent before hand the minds of all her
fellow-servants who by their steady attachments are far more deserving
than herself of favor.
I was apprehensive (and so informed Mr.
Wolcott) that if she had any previous notice more than could be avoided of
an attempt to send her back, that she would contrive to elude it; for
whatever she may have asserted to the contrary, there is no doubt in this
family of her being seduced, and enticed off by a Frenchman, who was
either really, or pretendedly deranged, and under that guise, used to
frequent the family; and has never been seen here since [the] girl
decamped. We have indeed, lately been informed thro' other channels that
she went to Portsmouth with a Frenchman, who getting tired of her, as is
presumed, left her; and that she had betaken herself to the needle, the
use of which she well understood, for a livelihood.
About the epoch I have mentioned she
herself was very desirous of returning to Virginia; for when Captn.
Prescot was on the point of sailing from Portsmouth to Federal City [D.C.]
with his family, she offered herself to his lady as a waiter, told her she
had lived with Mrs. Washington (without entering into particulars), and
that she was desirous of getting back to her native place and friends.
Mrs. Prescot either from not wanting a Maid Servant, or presuming that she
might have been discarded for improper conduct, declined (unlucky for Mrs.
Washington) taking her.
If she will return to her former service
without obliging me to use compulsory means to effect it her late conduct
will be forgiven by her Mistress, and she will meet with the same
treatment from me that all the rest of her family (which is a very
numerous one) shall receive. If she will not you would oblige me, by
resorting to such measures as are proper to put her on board a Vessel
bound either to Alexandria or the Federal City. Directed in either case,
to my Manager at Mount Vernon; by the door of which the Vessel must pass,
or to the care of Mr. [Tobias] Lear [Washington's secretary] at the last
mentioned place, if the Vessel should not stop before it arrives at that
Port.
I do not mean however, by this request,
that such violent measures should be used as would excite a mob or riot,
which might be the case if she has adherents, or even uneasy Sensations in
the Minds of well disposed Citizens; rather than either of these
should happen I would forego her Services altogether, and the example also
which is of infinite[ly] more importance. The less is said beforehand, and
the more celereity is used in the act of shipping her when an opportunity
presents, the better chance Mrs. Washington who is desirous of receiving
her again) will have to be gratified.
We had vastly rather she should be sent
to Virginia than brought to this place, as our stay here will be but short
[Washington's second term was nearing its end]; and as it is not unlikely
that she may, from the circumstances I have mentioned, be in a state
of pregnancy. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A few unspoken
assumptions in Washington's letters to Whipple stand out; a more sensitive
reader might well find others. It is assumed that Oney Judge, having been
well treated by the Washingtons, could have no reason to run away
("without the least provocation"); the possibility that she
might have found slavery objectionable in itself, regardless of her
treatment, isn't considered. It is also assumed that she must have been "seduced" into escaping, being too "simple"
to be able to decide to leave, or to leave, by herself. But the
"Frenchman," if he existed (which Whipple himself doubted),
seems never to have been identified; the fact of Oney's pregnancy in 1796
is dubious, as her first child may have been born in 1797 or 1798. The
implication that she and her fellow slaves, or their ancestors, had
voluntarily entered in to some sort of contract with their owners, to
which Oney had been "unfaithful," leads one to wonder just when
this is supposed to have occurred. It is also noteworthy that Whipple's
suggestion that Oney's return be negotiated through the courts, as if she
had the rights of a United States citizen, is quietly ignored.
An interview with Ona Maria Staines (as
she was then) by "T. H. A." of Stratham (Probably a
misreading of the initials of Joseph A. Adams [1818-1860]) was printed in
the Granite Freeman of May 1845, when she was close to 80
years of age, and had been living on today's Dearborn Road in Greenland
for several decades. Whether accurately or not, Ona mentioned no help from
any white "Seducer," but gave the impression that she and her
black friends in Philadelphia had been perfectly capable of accomplishing
her escape: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Being
a waiting maid of Mrs. Washington, she was not exposed to any particular
hardships. If asked why she did not remain in his [sic] service, she gives
two reasons, first, that she wanted to be free; secondly, that she
understood that after the decease of her master and mistress, she was to
become the property of a grand-daughter of theirs, by the name of Custis,
and that she was determined never to be her slave.
Being asked how she escaped, she replied
substantially as follows, "Whilst they were packing up to go to
Virginia, I was packing to go, I didn't know where; for I knew that if I
went back to Virginia, I never should get my liberty. I had friends among
the colored people of Philadelphia, had my things carried there
beforehand, and left Washington's house while they were eating
dinner."
She came on board a ship commanded by
Capt. John Bolles, and bound to Portsmouth, N.H. In relating it, she
added, "I never told his name till after he died, a few years since,
lest they should punish him for bringing me away." |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The man Ona meant
was Capt. John Bowles. He took the sloop Nancy to
Philadelphia in May 1796, returning around June 1, according to the
Portsmouth papers. This must have been the trip on which Ona came to New
Hampshire. Bowles became a successful merchant and a Portsmouth town
officer, and died in 1837, aged 73.
Joseph Whipple addressed his last letter
on the subject of Ona Judge to President Washington on Dec. 22, 1796: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I
sincerely lament the ill success of my endeavours to restore to your Lady her
servant on the request of Mr Wolcott -- It had indeed become a subject of
Anxiety to me on an Idea that her services were very valuable to her
mistress and not readily to be replaced.
My mode of proceeding then, was adapted
to my feelings on the Occasion, for I conceived that a Servant (in her
employment especially) returning voluntarily [is] of infinitely more value
in the estimation of her employer than one taken forceably like a felon to
punishment -- wherefore I gave her notice -- this notice however was not
given until the Vessel [it was] intended to convey her in was on the point
of sailing -- nor would it then have been given had I not drawn from her
an Acknowledgement of a desire to return before she knew I was authorized
to send her back, -- It was the circumstance of her Acquaintance
discovering her intention that defeated it.
I will now Sir agreeably to your desire
send her to Alexandria if it be practicable without the consequences which
you except -- that of exciting a riot or a mob -- or creating uneasy
sensations in the minds of well disposed Citizens -- the first cannot be
calculated before hand -- it will be governed by the popular opinion of
the moment --or the circumstances that may arise in the transaction. The
latter may be sought into and judged of by conversing with such persons
without discovering [i. e., revealing] the Occasion -- So ffar as I have
had opportunity I perceive that different sentiments are entertained on
this subject. -- At present there is no Vessel bound for Alexandria or
Philadelphia -- when there is [one] for the former place, I shall (if
practicable without such disagreeable consequences as I may think
repugnant to your wishes) execute your directions. -- I have deferred
answering your letter some days to find out the present retreat of the
Girl and yesterday discovered that she was lodged at a Free-Negro's --
that she is published for marriage agreeable to our laws in such cases
to a Mulatto. I have applied to the officer who certifies the publication
and requested of him to withhold the certificate. -- The farther measures
that may be proper I will give the utmost attention to. --
It has been remarked that there are many
Servants who have escaped from the Southern States into Massachusetts and
some to New Hampshire; -- If the practice encreases it will be very
injurious to many valuable Estates at the Southward, and such numbers of
persons unused to providing for themselves will become miserable and
a nuisance to the public. -- It were to be wished for the good of Society
as well as for the individuals interested that some means could be adopted
of a public nature to prevent this growing evil and that the abolition of
this species of servitude should be as gradual as has been heretofore
contemplated. -- I shall in all cases in which my services may be
acceptable to you be happy in rendering them & in executing your
commands. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The fact remains,
however, that Whipple had not carried out the Washingtons' wishes
and returned Ona to Virginia -- one wonders how eager he really was to do
so -- nor was he able to suppress entirely the publication of her
intentions of marriage with the "mulatto" he mentioned, John
Staines. Greenland's town records contain a notation by Thomas Philbrook,
town clerk, dated Jan. 8, 1797: "This may Certify that Mr. John
Staines and Miss Oney Judge was Published in this Town." Their
marriage was performed by Dr. Samuel Haven in Portsmouth, and announced in
the Jan. 14 Gazette. The Washingtons are reported to have attempted
to induce Ona to return to them subsequently, but without success, and the
Staineses settled down in Portsmouth. Two daughters were born to them,
Eliza, in 1797 or 1798, and Nancy, probably in 1802. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|